it's the eyelashes that make it uncanny for me. Because they're white instead of dark, they don't provide the visual border for her eyes, so her pupils/irises look like dots on a doll's face
I'd like to thank Foxygen for providing the real-world confirmation that non-black eyelashes look weird.
Base +7, thusgrim +6, SerGeorge +6, TommyTime +6, ad4tgh45tr3ef3g +4