I would rather have 1 doujin with the guy who did Tamamo design over 100 doujins of setouchi, just saying.

Base +6, hatrix42 +7, zayin +8, kyuubisonic +9, nopenopenopee +7, ScarletAngel +5, conkikhon +5, 6PUTOCTb +10, Mister H +6, x392 +10, donek +6

well setouchi is the idea guy afterall

Base +5, bigdemon123 +7, InsaneDragon +4

Not every idea can be a hit out of the park.

Personally, I really liked the Alma/Granberia story (dat ending >.>). The alternate high school setting one felt like a pile of missed opportunities.

Base +9, Seiguld +7, InsaneDragon +4

is that several doujin Setouchi main taste is not all, what more or less me included, have to admit it was this better than others that part made me laugh quite sack page 30 and 46 doujin.

@Timel the truth would be an amazingly doujin with the author of Tamamo

Base +7

Setouchi has made some good MGs. I do like Promestein, as well as Nanabi, Sphinx, and the Kraken. I do like Tamamo more (made by Jingai Modoki), and a lot of the works by frfr (maker of ones like the Queen Harpy, Queen Mermaid, Nekomata, Cupid, and everybody's favorite straight shota himself, Luka). Frfr would do wonders if he did MGQ doujins.

On a side note, does anybody wonder why Monster Girl Games constant have a shota as the protagonist? This game, the Violated Hero games, a good chunk of RPG Maker games. What about young boys makes a monster girl go weak in the knees? One of the great mysteries of the universe...

Base +6

@BigMatt1821

It's the size/strength difference. You take a monster girl like the Harpies or your average Lamia, and I can easily see her holding Luka down while taking advantage of him. You have the same scene but with a bodybuilder or something, and it becomes a little harder to believe. At least from a meta "this is why the artist did this" perspective. From an in-universe perspective, they might just be easier to subdue for a similar reason.

Base +6, CopyBotJ +4

i lost it at page 30

Base +6, raaaa125 +6

Honestly I think he draws decently enough when he's not drawing a monster he designed.

His designs are what I really don't like.

Base +6, AntiShisno -7, sockpuppet56 +4

and we now have a doujin thats about that single scene

Base +7